Rethinking autonomy, selfdetermination and sovereignty. Jane hofbauers assessment is conducted through an analysis of the different tiers of selfdetermination, ranging from the right to exercise external selfdetermination, the right to exercise forms of autonomy as a. Autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination the accommodation of conflicting rights. Ryan university of rochester selfdetermination theory sdt is an empirically based theory of human motivation, development, and wellness.
This chapter argues that legitimate states have a right to political selfdetermination, and external parties wrongly disrespect the citizens of a legitimate state when they interfere with this states dominion over its domestic affairs. It is a property which all independent states possess and is utilized when a nation enters into treaties, legislates, or engages in the international political scene. See generally antonio cassese, self determination of peoples. In order to do so, i investigate the analogy between sovereignty and individual.
Sovereignty refers to the inherent ability of a state to govern itself. Define and discuss with the students the ideas of sovereignty and selfdetermination. Hurst hannum demands for autonomy or minority rights have given rise to conflicts, often violent, in every region of the world and under every political system. Reducing the right of selfdetermination to a right to autonomy is not in accordance with the idea of selfdetermination as a human right and neither is the denial of the right of secession in absoluto.
James irving, selfdetermination and colonial enclaves. Selfdetermination generally applies to people, not states. The word free is more complicated, but it too has an ambiguity similar to that of autonomous and independent, especially when applied to nations and states. Pdf on dec 1, 1993, brendan oleary and others published autonomy, sovereignty and self determination. The most interesting and most ambitious attempt to do so, comes from those philosophers who claim that sovereignty is in principle incompatible with the rule of law. Article on the right to external self determination. Aug 17, 2014 the concept of autonomy as selfsovereignty is developed in this essay through an examination of the thought of american transcendentalist philosophers emerson and thoreau. Read the fulltext online edition of autonomy, sovereignty, and self determination. In order to explain the importance of sovereignty and selfdetermination to young students, have them think back to lessons that focus on how biodiversity is good for the planet. Sovereignty has an inverse relationship with power in comparison to autonomy. To define selfdetermination this way does not, however, add content to the concepts mentioned. State, sovereignty, and selfdetermination liechtenstein.
Selfdetermination of indigenous peoples within the human. Hannum, hurst autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination the accommodation of conflicting rights. The resulting conception of sovereignty, sovereignty as autonomy, shows that sovereignty and the rule of law are utterly compatible. The accommodation of conflicting rights procedural aspects of international law hannum, hurst on. A macrotheory of human motivation, development, and health edward l. The right to self determination is referred to in the preamble of chapter 1 of the gibraltar constitution, and, since the united kingdom also gave assurances that the right to self determination of gibraltarians would be respected in any transfer of sovereignty over the territory, is a factor in the dispute with spain over the territory. Sovereignty, independence, and selfdetermination 361 palestinian autonomy in the west bank. Autonomy, sovereignty, and self determination book description.
In the course of the release, senator mcmullan said the following. Although autonomy does entail some leeway in the realm of selfliberty, the freedom is the result of a trickledown phenomenon where power is derived in a larger, more authoritative entity. Selfdetermination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic. Feel free to use any of them for academic or research purposes, but please note that to use any of the scales for commercial purposes, you will need to seek permission from edward l. Still, be prepared to fight for your rights, but this time with the best tools, indigenous rights. India could not resolve the dilemma of choosing between national integrity and right of selfdetermination of a part of the nation. First, internal, dimension, which means a sovereign state is supreme to all institutions and individuals which are within the territory of that st.
This theory suggests that people are able to become selfdetermined when their needs for competence, connection, and autonomy are fulfilled. The principle of selfdetermination the term selfdetermination entered political discourse in the period. Hurst hannum, autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination. Selfdetermination theory suggests that people are motivated to grow and change by three innate and universal psychological needs. It is conceived as the quality of living in accordance with ones inner nature or genius. Martti koskenniemi, national selfdetermination today. Demands for autonomy or minority rights have given rise to conflicts, often violent, in every region of the world and under every political system.
Autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination the accommodation of conflicting rights hurst hannum. If youre interested in using a questionnaire or scale to measure selfdetermination, this website is an excellent resource. The project on state, sovereignty, and selfdetermination addresses issues of boundaries, identity, variants of autonomy, governance, selfdetermination, selfdeterminations potential devolutive and stateshattering capabilities, and the emerging version of selfdetermination as defining ones own destiny. This theory suggests that people are able to become self determined when their needs for competence, connection, and autonomy are fulfilled. Relating transnational democracy to local autonomy carol c. Sovereignty, independence, and selfdetermination selfdetermination australian view on 1 february 1995, in geneva, the australian delegation made a statement to the fiftyfirst session of the united nations commission on human rights in relation to the right of peoples to selfdetermination. It states that people, based on respect for the principle of equal rights and fair equality of opportunity, have the right to freely choose their sovereignty and. For a good crosssection of such writing, see the bibliographies in i. Using selfdetermination theory as a guiding framework, this study examined whether perceptions of god as autonomy supportive and controlling were related to individuals belief in a transcendent. The right of a people to selfdetermination is a cardinal principle in modern international law commonly regarded as a jus cogens rule, binding, as such, on the united nations as authoritative interpretation of the charters norms. Selfdetermination theory sdt is an approach to human motivation and personality that uses traditional empirical methods while employing an. The architects of the agreement no doubt hoped that the cultural, political, and historical differences between.
What is difference between sovereignty and autonomy. The success of singapore and the failure of theory 2008 12 s. The theory focuses on types, rather than just amount, of motivation, paying particular. Many philosophers, past and present, have attempted to eradicate the notion of sovereignty. The concept of autonomy as selfsovereignty is developed in this essay through an examination of the thought of american transcendentalist philosophers emerson and thoreau. Autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination hurst hannum published by university of pennsylvania press hannum, hurst. Autonomy, sovereignty, and self determination hurst hannum published by university of pennsylvania press hannum, hurst. Sovereignty in the exercise of the right to selfdetermination detangles the relationship between a number of principles of international law and the exercise of sovereign power. Pdf rethinking autonomy, selfdetermination and sovereignty. The concept of intrinsic motivation, or engaging in activities for the. Redefining autonomy, selfdetermination and sovereignty as a.
Sovereignty, territorial integrity and right of self. Closely associated with this right is the right to territorial integrity and the prohibition of intervention in internal affairs. University of pennsylvania press, 1996 law 534 pages. Self determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and wellbeing richard m. Jane hofbauers assessment is conducted through an analysis of the different tiers of selfdetermination, ranging from the right to exercise external self. The accommodation of conflicting rights procedural aspects of international law. The statist conception equates selfdetermination with the familiar idea of state autonomy. Group autonomy and state sovereignty oxford scholarship. Martti koskenniemi, national self determination today. Every tension has a breaking point, and that breaking point has usually resulted in revolutionary wars ones that were eventually welcomed and accepted after they. In each of the nine situations, autonomy, selfgovernment, or selfdetermination is demanded by a group within an existing state, in order to protect the groups culture. The word free is more complicated, but it too has an ambiguity similar to that of autonomous and independent, especially.
Autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination hurst hannum. Using self determination theory as a guiding framework, this study examined whether perceptions of god as autonomy supportive and controlling were related to individuals belief in a transcendent. Gould contemporary practice and problems for theory the practical context for the theoretical re. Most of the writing on autonomy consists either of individual case studies or scattered general references embedded in works on selfdetermination, sovereignty, or statehood. Autonomy sovereignty and self determination the accommodation of conflicting rights procedural aspects of international law download autonomy sovereignty and self determination the accommodation of conflicting rights procedural aspects of international law ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub, and mobi format. Define and discuss with the students the ideas of sovereignty and self determination. A right of autonomy within international law might help resolve intrastate conflicts between ethnic groups before they escalate into civil war and demands for secession. Selfdetermination, relational autonomy, and transnational. In most cases, the minority group is a minority which has felt disadvantaged and discriminated against. History of selfdetermination selfdetermination in international law is the legal right for a people14 to attain a certain degree of autonomy from its sovereign. This implies that the right to selfdetermination seems at odds with the territorial integrity of any state or region. Understood in these terms, selfdetermination is an enduring notion in international thought. India could not resolve the dilemma of choosing between national integrity and right of self determination of a part of the nation. See generally antonio cassese, selfdetermination of peoples.
With the end of the cold war, ethnic conflict appears to be reemerging as subnational groups fight to be heard and represented. If you feel the need, go ahead and check your thesaurus now. Senator mcmullan reaffirmed australias commitment to israels security within internationally recognised borders and the right of the palestinians to self. The accommodation of conflicting rights find, read and cite all the research you need on. Traditionally, sovereignty has been the most important feature of state. In this context it may be pertinent to quote hurst hannum autonomy, sovereignty and selfdetermination who maintains that neither sovereignty nor. Defining the right to selfgovernment when cracking open a thesaurus to find synonyms for freedom, one will undoubtedly come across the words autonomy and sovereignty.
The principle of selfdetermination imposes a negative duty on states to refrain from interference in one anothers affairs. The tension between national sovereignty and selfdetermination has always been at the heart of democratic principles, but both cannot be found within the same borders. Territorial integrity and the right to selfdetermination. These are important suggestions about how to use a flexible approach to sovereignty and the right to ethnic selfdetermination to create a just and ordered multinationstate system. Download pdf autonomy sovereignty and self determination. The importance of sovereignty and selfdetermination.
In order to explain the importance of sovereignty and self determination to young students, have them think back to lessons that focus on how biodiversity is good for the planet. Redefining autonomy, selfdetermination and sovereignty as a tool of peace many nationalist struggles and ethnic conflicts in northeast india have been rooted in the assertion of the idea of autonomy, selfdetermination and sovereignty. This freedom is codified in the european convention on human rights echr. Self determination theory suggests that people are motivated to grow and change by three innate and universal psychological needs. Restoring indigenous selfdetermination is a process that requires a dialogue between governments and indigenous peoples, in which both seek to create a new situation of relational autonomy, based on the core principle of nondomination expressed in the declaration. Relating transnational democracy to local autonomy. Through an analysis of contemporary international legal norms and an examination of several specific case studiesincluding hong. Redefining autonomy, selfdetermination and sovereignty as. The principle of selfdetermination is critical to the development of human rights law, yet it has been an ongoing issue of contention because it is claimed by states in particular to challenge state sovereignty.
Refusal to grant the right of self determination frequently leads to the violation of the human rights of nationally, ethnically, racially or religiously defined population groups. The accommodation of conflicting rights find, read and cite all. These concepts provide moral legitimacy to the struggles in the region, even to those that often become violent. While this book is written from the perspective of an international lawyer, its focus is on individuals and groups rather than states, the traditional subjects and objects of international law. This chapter focuses on the content of southern sudanese autonomy as embodied in the 1972 addis ababa agreement, which ended a seventeenyearlong civil war, and the constitutional arrangements adopted the following year. Deci university of rochester human beings can be proactive and engaged or, alterna tively, passive and alienated, largely as a function of the. At the same time, this conception conserves what i believe to be the normative core of our modern notion of sovereignty. Through an analysis of contemporary international legal norms and an examination of several specific case studiesincluding hong kong, india, the transnational problems of the kurds and saamis, nicaragua, northern ireland, spain, sri lanka, and. In this context it may be pertinent to quote hurst hannum autonomy, sovereignty and self determination who maintains that neither sovereignty nor self determination is an absolute right. Refusal to grant the right of selfdetermination frequently leads to the violation of the human rights of nationally, ethnically, racially or religiously defined population groups. The purpose of this paper is to repel this latter attack. In wellmans view, a state is legitimate just in case it satisfactorily protects the human rights of its constituents and respects the rights of all. These are important suggestions about how to use a flexible approach to. Autonomy definition, independence or freedom, as of the will or ones actions.
430 1387 403 1195 1004 555 287 452 544 736 1197 1244 1118 752 1073 20 933 807 678 569 1454 329 11 403 35 379 535 1085 292 259 662 949 227 185